Was Jesus born at an inn?

Preston Sprinkle —  December 15, 2011 — 5 Comments

Despite what is ubiquitously portrayed in nativity scenes, Christian folklore, and every English translation that I’m aware of, there’s a good chance that Jesus’ parents never visited an inn in Bethlehem to give birth to the Christ-child.

Here are three reasons why.

First, Bethlehem was a very small rural village at this time—population of only a few hundred people. Historically, then, it would be extremely unlikely that there was a commercial inn at such a small village. Inns existed in cities that attract travelers (merchants, religious pilgrims, etc.), or because the city is on major travel route and far from a large town. Bethlehem is neither. So it’s unlikely that there was some sort of ancient Motel 6 doing business in the village.

Second, unlike our American culture, families in ancient Palestine would be expected to host relatives during their travel. Since Joseph and Mary are originally from Bethlehem, they would have had lots of near and distant relatives there to stay with. Culturally, then, even if there was a Motel 6 in Bethlehem (which is unlikely), it would have been incredibly offensive for this Davidic couple to seek shelter there. They would have gone straight to the house of a relative.

But doesn’t the Bible say that they stayed at an inn? Well, not exactly.

Third, Luke 2:7 says: “Then she gave birth to her firstborn Son, and she wrapped Him snugly in cloth and laid Him in a feeding trough—because there was no room for them at the inn” (HCB), but the word for “inn” is kataluma, which can refer to a number of different types of lodging places. It can mean “inn” in the traditional sense, but it can also refer to a room (or spare room) in a house, and this latter meaning is probably what’s intended here in Luke 2. Luke does actually refer to an inn later in Luke 10:34 (where the Samaritan brought the half-dead man), but he uses a different word there: pandokeion (“inn”) and not kataluma. In fact, the only other time Luke uses kataluma is in Luke 22:11, where it clearly means a room in a house, not an inn.

Therefore, once we dig deeper into the historical, cultural, and linguistic background of Luke 2, it’s likely that Joseph and Mary went to the house of a relative to find refuge and deliver the child. However, upon arriving, they discovered that there was no room for them in this house—perhaps other relatives were already taking up the spare room, or perhaps it was a small, one room-house and it was already too crowded. Either way, Joseph had to take his pregnant wife to the stench-filled courtyard where the animals were kept to deliver the Messianic King.

Got time for some reasoned speculation?

If this interpretation is correct, and there is every reason to believe that it is, then why would the relatives of Joseph and Mary not give up their home or spare room to let Mary—a woman 9 months pregnant—give birth to her child? The text doesn’t say, but it is quite odd that Mary is forced to have the baby with the animals. It’s not certain, but perhaps there is a subtle critique of such an inhospitable act. Maybe the family knew of Mary’s reputation as a whore—an unmarried 15 year old carrying a child—and so they kicked her to the curb, or out with the animals, to show the surrounding villagers that they did not approve of her immorality.

Now, none of this is conclusive, but the historical scenario does suggest it. If so, this gives deeper meaning to what John 1:11 will say of Jesus: “He came to his own, and his own people did not receive him.” This is of course true of Jesus’ rejection by the Jews, but it may well be foreshadowed here in his birth, when we was rejected by his own relatives before he was even born.

Another proof, if proof were needed, that the incarnation was a radical act of grace, penetrating the depths of humility and shame.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Preston Sprinkle

Preston Sprinkle

Posts

I'm married to a beautiful wife and we have four kids (3 girls and a boy). I've been teaching college level Bible and Theology classes for a few years now (since 2007), and enjoy hanging out with my family, running, surfing, and life in SoCal. Before I became a teacher, I was in school. Lots and lots of school. I did a B.A. and M.Div here in SoCal, and then did a Ph.D. in Scotland in NT studies. Before coming to EBC, I taught at Nottingham University for a semester, and Cedarville University for a couple of years. Along with surfing, I also love to research and write, and I've written a few things on Paul, Early Judaism, and Hell.
  • yvonne wilber

    I thought they brought the animals in at night to a dug-out part of the house, with the eating trough (manger) carved out at floor level. This protected the livestock from wild beasts and thieves. Which means that although there was not room in the guest room, Joseph and Mary were able to bunk down on the floor of the living room. I don’t remember where I read that, but it was at EBC.

    • http://prestonsprinkle.com Preston Sprinkle

      Good thoughts, Yvonne! There’s actually a number of different suggestions concerning the exact layout of the house, feeding trough, location of animals, etc. But there’s nothing that clear in the text (i.e. Luke 2) that helps determine this. Historically, it all depends on the type of house that they would have stayed at, but this is impossible to determine. In a typical four-room house, the animals would have been kept in the courtyard at night, which would have been safe. And this is the scenario that I’ve assumed in my blog, though it’s not the only scenario. Feeding troughs could have been carved out in the floor, or sometimes they were attached to the wall of the courtyard.

  • Bob Childress

    What? You just ruined my sermon for Sunday. Now I have to start over. Merry Christmas my friend.

  • http://prestonsprinkle.com Preston Sprinkle

    Thanks Dean. Hey, we still need to go surfing sometime! Shoot me an email.
    preston@eternitybiblecollege.com

  • Dean Knudsen

    Very good stuff Preston. I love when people do their homework!! Hope all is well with you and the family. Blessings.